Sixty minutes weren’t enough to decide a new NXT Champion thanks to Adam Cole’s miraculous, buzzer-beating final fall on NXT Super Tuesday.

Now Cole will go one-on-one with Finn Bálor for the NXT Title to kick off NXT Super Tuesday II tonight. 

Bálor had seemingly all but clinched his second NXT Championship, striking at the perfect time with a Coup de Grace on Tommaso Ciampa and pinning The Blackheart with less than 20 seconds left to take a 2-1-1-1 lead over the other three competitors.

Cole then burst back into the ring, blindsiding The Prince with the Last Shot and pinning him just before time expired to finish in a 2-2 tie.

Following the dead heat conclusion, both men staked their claim to the NXT Title in a tumultuous scene that prompted William Regal’s arrival.

The NXT General Manager ruled immediately that Bálor and Cole — owners of the two longest NXT Title reigns in history — will face off in a one-fall bout next week to definitively crown an NXT Champion.

Which man will earn the black-and-gold brand’s top prize? Find out on NXT Super Tuesday II tonight at 8/7 C on USA Network!