As she battles confidence issues of her own, Paige has an unexpected encounter with an emotional fan.

On this week’s “Total Divas,” the answer to the question you’ve always secretly stowed away in that little place in the back of your mind: What would Paige look like with a tan?

The answer? Pretty good, though Paige is not all that down with changing her signature look to fit the dress code Alicia Fox thinks she needs for the WWE Hall of Fame ceremony. Despite Foxy and Natalya’s best attempts to beautify the goth princess by draping her in formalwear and bronzer, The Diva of Tomorrow can’t settle on a look that suits her. However, after a serendipitous encounter with a fan who says Paige’s uniqueness helped her cure an eating disorder, Paige comes to the realization that she should, and will, simply be herself. Doc Martens and a dress, here we come.

Watch the makeover attempt |  Photos from this week's episode

Among the other WrestleMania festivities that are ramping up is a scheduled father-daughter autograph signing session with Natalya and Jim “The Anvil” Neidhart, the first of its kind. Unfortunately, Neidhart is ejected from his rehabilitation center for throwing a temper tantrum, and Nattie worries that being surrounded by his old buddies will lead to a relapse. Her fears are put to rest when Neidhart makes it to the signing in one piece, and she gets to see her dad in all his glory.

On the other end of the spectrum is Eva Marie, who’s still catching flak on all sides from the Divas for reasons that nobody can really pin their finger on. The only woman to step to her defense is Naomi, who openly confronts Alicia over her treatment of Eva, leading to a shouting match that is, at least for the moment, silenced.

The Bellas, meanwhile, continue their slow, steady march along different paths in life. Even as Divas Champion Nikki continues to assert herself as the locker room boss, a pregnancy false alarm only reinforces Brie’s belief that she’s ready to be a mother, and husband Daniel Bryan agrees to a fertility test so they can begin to plan for their future.

Next week: Eva ruins WrestleMania? “Total Divas” airs Tuesdays at 9/8 C on E!.